Revival in progressThe National Development Foundation is being restarted in 2026. This site was published on 19 October 2026 and is being updated as records are found.How to help
Role of non-governmental organizations in the improvement of minor irrigation systems in Sri Lanka
Proceedings of the IIMI and ARTI workshop at Digana, 17 and 18 March 1989, published as IIMI Working Paper 18 in 1990. Includes Upali Magedaragamage's paper on NDF's tank renovation and the discussion.
# Role of non-governmental organizations in the improvement of minor irrigation systems in Sri Lanka (IIMI Working Paper 18, 1990)
--- page 1 ---
Working Paper No. 18
ROLE OF N0"MENT ORGANIZATIONS IN THE I m \ / m T
OF MINOR IRRIGATION S k - S m IN SRI LANKA
Proceedings of a Workshop
held at
Digana Village, Kandy, Sri Lanka
17-18 m h 1989
Organized Jointly
by the
International Irrigation Managent Institute
and the
Agrarian Research a d Training Institute
M.H.S. hyaratne
and
Gamini Wickremasinghe
May 1990
"ATIONAL
IRRIGATION MANAc;EMEwT 1NSTI"E
Colombo, Sri Lanka
--- page 2 ---
11). 1990. R o l e of
International Irrigat.ion ,knagement,.istitUte (
nongovernmental Organizations in the improvement of minor irrigation systems
in Sri Lanka: Proceedings of a Workshop h e l d at Digana [-illage,Iiandy, Sri
Lanka. 17-18 March 1989. colornbo, S r i Latlk-a: IIYI. 4 t 76 p .
/organizations / irrigation systems / rehabilitation / rural developnent /
farmer participation / Sri L a n k 4
DD(:: 631.7
ISBN: 92-9090-130-3
Sunmary: An inherent feature of NGO interventions is the continuous
involvement of beneficiary farmers to create a sense of orvnership of the
system by farmers which would ultimately reduce the farmers’ dependency on
outside assistance. The Government of Sri Lanka has also encouraged these
assistance programs as operation and maintenance of minor irrigation systems
has become a heavy burden on the gdvernment. Therefore, the es-periences of
KGOs are of paramount importance to government organizations such as the
Irrigation Department and the Department of Agrarian Services that are
directly involved in minor irrigation work. The workshop on the role of NGOs
in the improvement of minor irrigation systems was organized to provide a
common forum to review these NGO interventions, to share their experience, and
t o learn lessons relevant for both government agencies and NCOs themselves.
Responsibility for the contents of this publication rests with the authors.
All rights reserved.
--- page 3 ---
............................
Purpose. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Objectives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Aknowledgements. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
viii
.............................
1
Background
Summary
v
vi
vii
OVERVIEW PAFms
Minor Irrigation systems in Sri Lanka
Gamini Wickremasinghe
...............
7
............
10
Nongovernmental Organizations in Sri Lanka
M. H. S . Dayaratne
PAPERS ON DIRECfLY INVOLVED N O S
Role of Freedom From Hunger Campaign
in the Improvement of Minor Irrigation Systems
inSriLanka
Dunstan Fernando
...........................
Minor Irrigation Tank Renovation Pro.ject of
National Development Foundation
Upali Magedaragamage
.................
FFHC & ?JDF in the Renovation of Village Irrigation
Schemes: Some Comparisons and Contrasts in the
PlmingConcepts.
liapila P. Vimaladharma
........................
Role of Rural Development Societies in the
Improvement of Minor Irrigation Schemes
G. I<. G. Perera
..............
Discussion
............................
15
17
20
25
27
--- page 4 ---
PAP-
ON INDIRECTLY INVOLVED NGOs
Role of Sandaya in the Improvement of Minor
Irrigation Systems
Sama G u n a w a r d a n e
........................
NGOs as Facilitators in Minor Irrigation
Development: A Case Study from Hambantota District, Sri Lanka
Inge Jungeling
...
Role of Participatory Institute for Development
Alternatives in the Improvement of Minor
Irrigation Systems
S.P. Wickramarachchi
Discussion
29
32
........................
37
............................
39
PAPERS ON NGOS WITH FVIURE INTERVENTIONS
Role of CARE in the improvement
of Minor Irrigation Systems
M. C. C. Illangakoon
....................
40
Strategy of PLAN International in the Improvement
of Minor Irrigation Systems
Daya Peiris
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 43
Discussions
...........................
.........................
Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
BIBLIa?lRAPHY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Recommendations
LIST OF PARTICIPANTS
..........................
46
47
51
53
54
--- page 5 ---
Minor irrigation schemes in Sri Lanka have served as the "nucleus" for
villages since ancient times so that they are also called "village irrigation"
systems. These ancient hydraulic systems by origin and operation, have been
"Farmer-Managed Irrigation Systems" until they collapsed owing to the impact of
foreign invasions and colonialism.
Both British rulers of the early 20th century and successive governments of
independent Sri Lanka have paid much attention to refurbishing the ancient
abandoned Farmer-Managed Irrigation Systems through different types of
interventions. The colonial rulers made great attempts to revive the ancient
customary laws (sirith) for better management of these systems, and to
rehabilitate most of the ancient tanks and anicuts. During the post-independent
period, particularly during the last 25 years the Government of Sri Lanka
introduced a series of assistance programs aimed at rehabilitation, improvement,
and water management of small irrigation systems. These assistance programs
include the Village Irrigation Rehabilitation Project, the District Integrated
Rural Development Programs, and the Anuradhapura D r y Zone Agricultural Project.
It has been argued that these government interventions have caused the farmers
to become more dependent on the government which naturally resulted in the
deterioration of the traditional practice of self-management.
Apart from government interventions several Nongovernment Organizations
( N G O s ) are involved in different assistance programs, either solely for minor
irrigation or as part of their rural-development interventions. Out of these
NGOs, the Freedom From Hunger Campaign which is a government-organized NGO, the
National Development Foundation, andtheRural Development Societiesaredirectly
involved in the improvement of minor irrigation systems, while some other NGOs
such as Sarvodaya, the Participatory Institute of Development Alternatives, and
the Federation of Thrift and Credit Cooperative Societies help the process
indirectly. Recently several NGOs like the CARE International, the PLAN
International, and the Nation Builders' Association have identified some
assistance programs in this sector.
V
--- page 6 ---
Purpose
None of these NGO interventions have been carefully reviewed, and their
experiences have not been shared either horizontally or vertically among NGOs
themselves or with government organizations. An inherent feature of NGO
interventions is the continuous involvement of beneficiary farmers to create a
sense of ownership of the system by farmers which would ultimately reduce the
farmers’ dependency on outside assistance. The Government of Sri Lanka has also
encouraged these assistance programs as operation and maintenance of minor
irrigation systems has become a heavy burden on the government. Therefore, the
experiences of NGOs are of paramount importance to government organizations such
as the Irrigation Department and the Department of Agrarian Services that are
directly involved in minor irrigation work. The workshop on the role of NGOs
in the improvement of minor irrigation systems w a s organizedto provide a common
forum to review these NGO interventions, to share their experience, and to learn
lessons relevant for both government agencies and NGOs themselves.
--- page 7 ---
Objectives
The workshop was organized to achieve the following objectives:
a)
b)
c)
d)
e)
Review the various assistance strategies of NGOs.
Assess the results of the various programs including the physical
performance of the irrigation systems, the economic productivity of
agriculture, and the social welfare of the beneficiaries.
Compare the methods of farmer mobilization.
Assess the sustainability of irrigation-management practices.
Consider the policy implications for government programs.
The workshop was confined to only one day and comprised four sessions dealing
with the three different NGO interventions and group discussions,keeping in line
with the workshop objectives. The tight schedule restricted detailed discussion
of each individual presentation but the session discussions and group discussions
were quite lively, resulting in constructive group recomnendations.
A total of 35 participants and several observers took part in the workshop;
they includedrepresentatives of relevant NGOs, heads ofgovernmentagencieslike
the Department of Agrarian Services and the Agrarian Research and Training
Institute (ARTI), the International IrrigationManagement Institute (IIMI)staff,
Agriswiss, and the Australian Freedom From Hunger Campaign.
The workshop was co-organized by ART1 and IIMI.
vii
--- page 8 ---
Acknowledgements
Grateful appreciation is due to Dr. Roberto Lenton, Director General of IIMI
for his encouragement and support for the workshop and to M r . Nan& Abeywickrema,
Director, Field Operations, who opened the workshop on behalf of the Director
General. The ready and continuous support extended by Dr. David Groenfeldt as
the Irrigation Specialist in charge of Farmer-Managed Irrigation Systems is duly
acknowl&ed.
The continuous encouragement and support given by M r . Joe Alwis, Director,
ART1 and Dr. Douglas J. Merrey, Head, Sri Lanka Field Operations, IIMI, are
highly appreciated.
The ready response and cooperation of the invited
participants from seven NGOs who presented papers; and of Mr. Kapila
Vimaladharma, Coordinator, Agriswiss and M s . Inge Jungeling, consultant, IIMI,
who presented the two special evaluation papers are acknowledged gratefully.
The workshop and these proceedings were supported with funds provided by
the International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD) and the Federal
Ministry for Economic Cooperation (BMZ), West Germany. The AFlTI and the IIMI
shared the actual costs of publications from their own funds.
Last, but not least, the contribution of all the participants which made
the workshop a success is highly appreciated.
viii
--- page 9 ---
The papers presented are based on individual experiences of various N O S that
have either been in the process of implementing minor irrigationdevelopent work
or formulating such activities. Depending on the specific role that the NGOs
have played in the improvement of minor irrigation systems, the presentation was
divided into four categories. In fact, the workshop was structured in such a
way that these differences would be highlighted and attention drawn to them, at
the subsequent discussions. It was hoped that this particular way of structuring
the seminar would enable the participants to exchange views and learn from each
other's experience in a more fruitful and effective manner. The papers were thus
classified into: a) overview papers; b) papers by NGOs that prefer direct
intervention; c) papers by NGOs that prefer indirect involvement; and d) papers
by those who contemplate moving into the development process in the minor
irrigation sector.
It is important to underline the fact that N O S have differences in their
stated objectives although all these organizations work within the broad field
of rural development. Some organizations lay particular emphasis on the groups
that are placed at a disadvantageous position in the society. Others would
stress overall development. These differences resulted in the considerable
diversity that was observed in the individual papers. However the differences
are interesting at least from two points of view. First, it provided the logic
for structuring the workshop the way it was done. Second, it carried serious
implications and naturally raised questions as to the validity of the different
approaches or strategies which have been adopted by NGOs in the improvement of
the minor irrigation sector, given the country-specific situation of Sri M a .
The overview paper on minor irrigation systems in Sri Lanka deals with the
definitions, the identification of different types of minor irrigation systems,
and the socioeconomic assessment relating to the significance of this sector.
It highlighted the fact, that although in the past the role of the water users
in the construction and maintenance of the irrigation systems w a s primary, now
it is the role of the State that is emphasized. The farmers' associations are
helping the State machinery and as such play only a secondary role. It further
observes that the term "village irrigation systems''found in the literature, is
not truly meaningful in the context of Sri Lanka as a whole. It therefore argues
that the term "farmer-managed water-control systems" is a preferable term as it
incorporates all types of water-control systems such as tanks, anicuts, streams,
\;ater-lifting systems, and conveyance systems which have been adopted by farmers
in different agro-ecological environs. This definition takes care of the
farmers' problems as well; the farmers need water in and out of the field
whenever it is necessary.
1
--- page 10 ---
Following the historical account the paper discerns two significant factors,
the labor mobilization and the relationship with the government. Accordingly,
the paper highlights the following issues.
How to mobilize people and for what purpose? -- which means the question of
popular participation. What is the nature of the relationshipbetween the State
and the community and what form should it take? This means the appreciation of
the principle of devolution of power and authority to the communities and that
of joint-management systems and the issue of accountability. The paper takes
note of the penetration of State bureaucracy into the village and the need for
interaction with the available local expertise in regard to irrigation
technology. Having tracedthe changes in the institutional structure which have
implications for NGOs, the latter has to operate within this framework. In
socioeconomic, demographic, and political terms, the minor irrigation systems
are of major importance. Although several programs have been implemented to
further develop this sector the complexity of the process involved points
towards the need to understand these processes through systematic and regular
stud..
.
The overview paper on Nongovernmental Organizations in Sri Lanka deals with
the definitions and the types of Ncos as well as the government policy, and the
role and functions of NGOs in minor irrigation. The paper observes that the
term "Nonkvernment" can be contradictory since there is direct or indirect
involvement of the government for some of the NGOs. The United Nations system
uses the term "Private Voluntary Organization." However, the paper suggests
that the term "Voluntary Organization" may be more appropriate, for the reason
that participation is anyway intended to be voluntary. Any group that is
voluntarily around a cormon purpose could be an NGO or a Private Voluntary
Organization. Three broad groups i.e., international, national, and local have
been identified in terms of the differences in scale, scope, objectives,
structure, and level of operation. At the local level, the simplest type of
local NGO is a Grass-Roots Organization. According to the usual concept of an
NGO they are viewed as: a) being good at reaching the poor; b) using a
participatory process; c) being innovative and experimental; and d) carrying
their projects at low cost.
The paper observes that the national and
international NGOs follow too much of a top-down bureaucratic approach which has
jeopardized their claim for being bottom-up and participatory in working with
beneficiaries.
In Sri Lanka there are about 150 NGOs out of which 35 are international
organizations. Some of the G r a s s Roots Organizations have been organized into
formal bodies under the government. The only local NGO which does not receive
any support from a higher level and functions effectively is the Death Donation
Society. Only some NGOs engaged in agricultural and rural development have a
national-level structure. Although many NGOs have received financial and other
facilities from outside not all of them have fully utilized these resources
owing to organizational weaknesses. The government policy is one of noninterference and positive facilitation. Legal and administrative provisions and
procedures have been devised for the registration of NGOs.
The first NGO paper on the Freedom From Hunger Campaign Board titled the
Role of FFHC in Minor Irrigation Improvement describes that it has been carrying
2
--- page 11 ---
out a program of renovation and restoration of village tanks (both ancient tanks
and abandoned tanks) with a view to enhancing people's participation and poverty
alleviation, promoting of labor intensive projects, and upgrading
environment/ecology and general living standards of the people. Work is
organized through wew-sabha and all earthwork is done manually by the members
of this organization and their families. Approximately US$1.30
(Rs 4 0 ) is paid for one cubic foot (0.0283m3) of earthwork. By June 1989, 135
tanks had been completed and in about 100 tanks, work was in progress. All the
projects are funded by outside agencies. As a result of this program, land,
water, labor, and other natural resources have been better utilized. The main
lesson learnt relates to the need for simultaneous organization of tankrehabilitation work and community-developt work. Antong the ma.jor constraints
identified are the lack of experienced technical staff, introduction of new
methods and techniques, rigidity and high degree of centralization of the
Freedom From Hunger Campaign management system, insufficiency of funds, lack of
coordination, and comunication inefficiencies.
The National Development Foundation has carried out six major developnent
programs, at least four of which are connected with irrigation and water
management. It has started 16 selected minor irrigation renovation projects.
The farmers are involved in the preliminary investigations including the
technical surveys. Farmers' organizations are formed and a society fund is also
organized. The Department of Agrarian Services is also drawn in when the final
estimates and plans are prepared. Participation by the intended beneficiaries
and the association of the state agencies are the factors responsible for the
success of this program.
An attempt w a s made, in the paper on the Freedom From Hunger Campai m and
the National Development Foundation in the Renovation of Village Irrigation
Schemes, to compare and contrast the planning concepts as well as to relate the
planning concepts and methods to the different strategies of field
implementation. The comparison is acknowledged to be unfair given the
differences in objectives and circumstances. Yet the strategy of mobilizing
beneficiaries, labor, and their participation in construction, operation and
maintenance is about the same for both agencies. Most of the shortcomings of
the Freedom From Hunger Campaign would flow from its somewhat rigid adherence
to a "blueprint." Having conceptualized a "model village" said to have existed
in the past, planning has progressed toward resuscitation of a village of that
nature. Naturally it becomes a top-down imposition, consequently restricting
the scope or beneficiary participation from the very beginning, In contrast,
the National Development Foundation has adopted an open, pragmatic, and flexible
approach in deciding on the type of project.
The National Development
Foundation has no model. Its charismatic leadership and closeness to the rural
people are the major factors that characterize its approach.
Eking a resettlement project, the Freedom From Hunger Campaign conceived it
as a comprehensive one which encompasses technical, social, and organizational
aspects.
The perspective tends to make the project authority assume
responsibility and to direct all activities.
The National Development
Foundation on the other hand, has mobilized the services of the government
agencies in the area from the beginning. It was able to bring its renovated
tank within the normal field programs of the Department. In the process, the
3
--- page 12 ---
farmers have learnt a great deal from the National Development Foundation
officers and from their own collective experiences and are quite confident about
their own ability to sustain the renovated systems.
The paper on the Role of Rural Development Societies gives a full account
of the relevant historical development, organizational changes which have taken
place over the years, and deals with the minor irrigation work with which the
rural-development societies have been associated.
The projects included
rehabilitation of old village tanks in the dry zone as well as minor irrigation
works in the wet zone. Labor-intensive methods were employed in this connection
and assistance from the World Food Programme was obtained to make an incentive
payment for voluntary work done by the villagers. Under this project 6,000
tanks in the dry zone and 5,000 minor irrigation schemes in the wet zone were
to be rehabilitated. In the implementation of the project the government agent
was the central executive authority while the Rural Development Societies
functioned at the village level. The field staff of the Department of Rural
Development assisted in the process.
Although the project performed
satisfactorily at the beginning the progress was slowed down in the interim due
to drought and a cyclone. A n interim evaluation noted that the schemes in the
wet zone were too small for the World Food Programme assistance and that hardly
any technological support has been provided in the formulation or implementation
of the projects despite the involvement of the Government Agent. The provision
of structures such as spillways, outlet pipes etc., was not made in time by the
Irrigation Department while there were many delays in the financing process as
well. This led to the deterioration of the earth work completed even before
they were put to use by the villagers.
The first of the next group of papers is by Sarvodaya which describes
poverty as the manifestation of the inability of the individual to satisfy ten
integrated basic needs; environment, housing, education, water, health care,
clothing, cmunication, food, fuel, and spiritual and cultural needs. The
satisfaction of these needs should result in individual as well as village
awakening. Sarvodaya work is organized at five levels, namely, the Village,
the Gramodaya Division, the Sarvodaya Division, the District, and the Fkgion.
The Sarvodaya Technical Services Division prepares the project proposals
including social and economic analyses and offers them to the donor agencies.
The funds are channeled through the Sarvodaya Shramadana Sa.ngamaya.
Each
village would have a Shramadana Samitiya for the purpose of coordination. The
Sarvodaya farms have been established for the purpose of offering training in
matters related to farming systems. As such, water management is not within
the core program of Sarvodaya. This is because Sarvodaya is involved in the
broad area of rural development. It emphasizes mobilization of labor through
Shramadana (self-help),and this process requires people to build up and manage
their minor irrigation systems as well.
The paper titled NGOs as Facilitators in Minor Irrigation Development
proceeds from the point of view that there is a contradiction between the
diversity in minor irrigation systems and the rigidity of the government
programs.
Controlled irrigation management, the paper asserts, is only
sustainable if it is supported by the water users, particularly because the
innovations introduced often do not suit the interests of different water users.
The results have been meager and this is attributed mainly to the legal
4
--- page 13 ---
authority that remains in the hands of the officials. The intensity of staffing
and the budgetary constraints of the departments do not permit the village-level
officer to adequately cover the interests of the water users as well as the
constant monitoring of the system. It is argued that irrigation-management
responsibility should be, as much as possible, in the hands of the water users,
According to the writer, the need of a facilitator arises from the fact that
while the water users may be ignorant of the services that might be delivered
to them and may not co-operate, the Department of Agrarian Services is not wellgeared to engage itself in a complicated and time-consuming comunication
process with water users. The paper mentions that the NCOs provide assistance
in a variety of ways. It further observes that the government sponsored
village-level organizations provide services on the basis of supply rather than
of demand which dilutes the required commitment of the water users to the
system. Some N O S on the other hand, suffer from the project-specific nature
of their involvement (the budget has to be spent regardless of the commitment
of the beneficiaries). Furthermore, many water users have discovered the
benefit of mobilizing such funds for their own goals which do not necessarily
relate to improved irrigation management. The paper is based on the experience
of the Norwegian Agency for International Development-funded Hambantota
Integrated Ezural Development Project, The main conclusion relates to the need
to clarify the responsibilities between the NGOs, the intermediaries such as
project officials, and the government departments.
The paper titled "Role of Participatory Institute for Development
AlternatiE" reveals that it started functions in 1981 and has 15 researchers
who operate as catalytic interveners in selected locations in the districts of
Hambantota, Matara, Galle, Colombo, Anuradhapura, and Kandy. The objective of
this organization is to change the process of developnent in favor of the
economically and socially disadvantageous groups by way of supporting and
strengthening people's organizations and training their members in catalytic
skills for such a process. The poorer sections of the village society are
stimulated to undertake a scientific inquiry into poverty which results in
social awareness leading to change of fatalistic beliefs and search for action
to counter the impoverishment process. Consequently, the poorer groups begin
to improve their access to resources and enhance their confidence regarding
their own ability to change the reality. In this way a process of self-reliant
development is initiated. The case study of the Ranna vegetable producers' cooperative society is presented to illustrate how the above process has been at
work in Hambtota.
The last two presentations were on two NGOs having future programs; The
paper on CARE (Cooperative American Relief Everywhere) about,its Role in the
Improvement of Minor-Irrigation Systems gives details on the four-year project
on rehabilitation of minor irrigation tanks which has just been formulated and
presented to the donor agencies for funding. CARE has been involved in droughtrelief programs where small tanks were rehabilitated by the rural people
themselves who received food from CARE for work done. In due course, CARE
gained knowledge and experience with regard to the problems affecting the
agrarian communities in the dry zone. In addition CARE has also studied
relevant work done by the IIMI and the ARTI. The proposed project envisages
the rehabilitation of 280 minor irrigation tanks with a view to increasing
cropping intensity and promoting the cultivation of vegetables and fruits in
--- page 14 ---
the home gardens and the consumption of the same. The overall objective is to
increase the income and the quality of life of small farmers and their families.
The strategy adopted by CARE involves the co-operation of the relevant
government agencies and the beneficiaries. The farmer groups will be organized
and tank committees will be elected. The farmers’ contribution will be 25
percent of the estimated cost, and the provincial council and CARE will
contribute 25 percent and 50 percent, respectively. The Department of Agrarian
Services will provide technical assistance and heavy machinery. The project
also has a large training component. The monitoring and evaluation mechanism
involves field visits and observations, interviews with farmers and farm women,
and scrutinizing of records. Baseline data will be collected before the
commencement of work. At the end of the second year a formative evaluation will
be conducted. At the end of the fourth year there will be a final evaluation
which will measure the attainment of the final goal in terms of increases in
total income, cropping intensity, and consumption of crops produced in the home
gardens.
The paper on Plan International (PLAN)gives indications of its willingness
to assist the target families in the construction/renovation of minor-irrigation
systems in Gampola, Kandy, and Badulla where it has been operating programs in
health, education, comnunity development, and income- generating skills. The
criteria of PLAN for selecting minor irrigation systems for assistance focus on
target families, active beneficiary participation, and self-management of the
systems. The strategy of PLAN for mobilizing people participation is through
constant dialogue and active involvement of potential beneficiaries from the
identification to implementation and monitoring of the project. PLAN considers
the government institutions and other NCOs as valuable resources that should not
be wasted due to duplication of effects. It welcomes interaction with these
institutions to avoid such duplication and to ensure sustainability and
continuity once PLAN phases out of the area.
6
--- page 15 ---
Minor Irrigation Systems in Sri Lanka
Gamini Wickramasinghe
SOCIOEcoNoMIC I m A N C E OF MINOR IIRRIGATION SYSTWS
The area under the village tanks as a percent of total irrigated area is
about 40.
In relation to the total asweddumized area, the minor irrigation
sector accounts f o r about 25 percent. About 90 percent of the holdings under
minor irrigation are below 0.4 hectare (ha). This sector contributes
22 percent of the total rice production.
According to the surveys done by the Ministry of Agriculture and the
Department of Agrarian Services there are 11,897 village tanks of which 8927
( 7 5 percent) are located in the dry zone and 2970 (25 percent) in the wet zone.
The 1986 implementation program of the Department of Agrarian Services states
that there are 9796 anicuts and 9294 minor tanks in working order scattered
throughout the country. According to the Ministry of Lands and LandDevelopment
there are 23,000 minor irrigation systems throughout the island, whereas the
Freedom From Hunger Campaign puts it at 30,000village tanks of which 18,000 (60
percent) are not in working order. Thus there is no agreement over the exact
number of minor irrigation systems. Yet it is clear that there are a large
number of small-scale irrigation systems and the problem of exactitude is also
connected to the diversity of definitions used.
In demographic terms the minor irrigation sector is important because a
large number of families are dependent on or connected with it. Owing to the
vagaries of weather, their existence is precarious. As such, it is not
incorrect to say that poverty is more pronounced in this sector. Thus both
socially and politically, the minor irrigation sector assumes a great deal of
significance. Making improvements to this sector would help improve the living
standards of the people as well as arrest trends of migration whether from rural
to rural or from rural to urban. It is also acknowledged that there could be
important lessons learnt from understanding the process of work in the minor
irrigation sector which may be applicable to the major-irrigation sector at
least insofar as organization and management of crop production and operation
and maintenance of the canal system are concerned. Although in recent times
investments have been made and many organization have been implementing programs
in this sector there is yet a remarkable lack of understanding of the factors
involved in this process.
'p
7
--- page 16 ---
DEFINITIONS
The minor irrigation systems, also known as small-scale irrigation systems
are defined in the Agrarian Services Act of 1979 as one with a COllllllELnd area of
less than 200 acres ( 8 0 ha) and more than 10 acres ( 4 ha) serving at least 5
farm families. The responsibility for refurbishment of the tank lies with the
Irrigation Department while the operation and maintenance of the tank is the
responsibility of the Department of Agrarian Services which is expected to
enlist farmer participation. The rules and procedures for the preparation of
irrigation works adopted in 1939 defined village-irrigation work as those under
which the landholders do not, as a general rule, pay any rate but carry out the
earthwork and jungle clearing necessary for their construction and maintenance
in part or whole.
The Irrigation Ordinance of 1946 also defined minor
irrigation systems as those constructed and maintained by the farmers
themselves.
The International Irrigation Management Institute stresses
farmers' involvement in irrigation management when it is apt to use the term
"farmer-managed irrigation systems.
"
It appears that all these definitions have identified the role of the
community as well as the State in different periods of time in relation to
irrigation. The earlier definitions lay a major emphasis on the role of the
community whereas the current one underlines the role of the State. The earlier
definitions assumed that the village existed formally unconnected to the
government whereas the latter assumes that the village has lost its autonom,,and
it now exists formally and directly connected to the State. The irrigation
system now belongs to the State and the villagers are beneficiaries who are
supposed to treat the irrigation system as a communal property or a trust.
In Sri Lanka, the importance of irrigation differs fundamentally from area
to area. In the dry and intermediate zones it is a question of provision of
irrigation. In the wet zone it is a question of drainage. Therefore, the term
"farmer managed water control system" is, perhaps, a more applicable term in the
case of Sri Lanka as it allows the incorporation of all types of water-control
systems whether they are tanks, anicuts, wells, streams, water-lifting systems,
or water-conveyance systems. A water-control system is defined as having
several subsystems such as the delivery subsystem, the distributory subsystem,
and the drainage subsystem. This definition should also be appealing to the socalled beneficiaries whose problem is that they need water in and out of the
fields whenever necessary.
Historically, the early settlements were established where water w a s
available, i.e., on river banks. The crucial factor for the formation of
agricultural settlements was mobilization of labor for water control. On
account of the communal type of production relations there existed no class of
landowners.
Surrounded by jungles and other natural conditions these
communities existed with no formal linkages to the administration from the
government. Any one who could mobilize labor for the construction of a tank
could organize a settlement and claim proprietary rights over the use of land
thus asweddumized. The tanks which were constructed in this manner were called
8
--- page 17 ---
gamika vavi or village tanks. When the population grew beyond what the tankbased economy could afford, similar settlements were made in the same manner by
the members of the same community under a popular leader. In a social sense,
several such villages belonged to one community called variga. Sometimes several
small hamlets were constructed in the same locality around the original tank and
these were called gamg oda, which in fact belonged to one village. The leader
of the community used the title "Gamini" which meant popularly elected leader.
Thus, historically there have been two basic issues (which are also
important today): First, the question of how to mobilize labor, and for what
purpose?
In today's context, this is termed as the issue of popular
participation. Second, the question relating to the nature of the relationship
between the State and the community; this means how much power and authority be
devolved to the community and to what extent there should be administration from
the government.
The Irrigation Ordinance of 1867 gave legislative authority to the Public
Works Department to repair village tanks. By 1889 as many as 2250 small tanks
had been repaired. This process was necessitated by the perceived need for the
preservation of peasants as a special group and the furtherance of peasant
proprietorship on the one hand and the need to reduce food import bill as well
as collect public revenue through taxation, on the other. The restoration of
tanks was achieved through the imposition of forced labor upon the peasantry
although the Rajakariya system was abolished in 1832. In this process the
isolated "one tank-one village" typ& of social formations were linked to the
Central Government through a unified system of administration. New government
institutions and a hierarchy of both British and Sri Lankan officials with a
knowledge of the new procedures were superimposed on the existing social
structure. This newly imposed structure came to be a permanent feature in the
social formations. These officials filled the absence of landowners who could
purchase land from the peasants who failed to pay taxes or whenever the
government sold or promoted land sales. The purchase of land by these officials
resulted in absentee landlordism as well as a complex nexus of production and
exchange relations. Once the class of landowners was thus created, the
development of the rest of the agrarian hierarchy proceeded at its own pace.
The village now having lost its autonomv remained connected to the central
administration and these connections as a rule were through the top level of the
village-agrarian hierarchy.
It is seen that the new set of productions and the institutional structures
(including bureaucracy) constitute important dimensions which impinge on the
process-making improvements to the minor irrigation systems. The relevant
issues to the nongovernmental organizations which are working in this area,
relate to the identification of production relations and the social and
institutional structure of the community which eitffer inhibit or promote change.
9
--- page 18 ---
Nongovernmental Organizations in Sri Lanka
M.H.S. D a y ~ ~ ~ ~ t n e
WHAT ARE NGm?
Independent voluntary organizations free from government control and
committed to positive changes in the communities where they work is one
definition of an NGO. The term "nongovernmental" can also be controversial
since there is direct or indirect involvement of the government for some of the
NGOs.
The United Nations system uses "Private Voluntary Organization" rather
than NGO (Tedler,Judith 1982). The term "Voluntary Organization" may be more
appropriate for these autonomous bodies because people volunteer to participate.
Generally, any informal group of people voluntarily organized around a
common purpose could be an NGO or a Private Voluntary Organization. NGOs differ
from one another in terms of their scale, scope, objectives, structure, and
level of operation. NGOs can be divided into three broad groups:
1)
2)
3)
International
National
Local
International NGOs may have their operations in a few or many countries;
national NGOs are characterized by a network of their operation within a context
of a country following a top-down control. Local NGOS are more autonomous
bodies in the context of their restricted functions within a confined
jurisdiction, and may be either localized or cover one or a few villages. The
simplest type of local NGO could also be categorized as G r a s s Roots
Organizations.
The objectives of the NGOs at any level may be religious, cultural, social,
economic and/or environmental. According to the usual concept of NGOS (or
Private Voluntary Organizations), they have several themes of action. They are
viewed as: 1 ) being good at reaching the poor; 2 ) using participatory processes
of project implementation; 3 ) being innovative and experimental; and 4)
carrying out their project at low cost.
Often the criticism leveled against well-organized N O S (both international
and national) is that they follow too much of a top-down bureaucratic approach
which has jeopardized their claim for being bottom-up and participatory in
working with beneficiaries.
*
10
--- page 19 ---
The NGO sector in Sri Lanka comprises a diversity of NGOs involved in
community developnent. The term NGO in the Sri Lankan context is rather
debatable, as the government is often directly or indirectly involved. Many
local-level NCOs, e.g., Rural Development Societies, Young Farmer Societies and
Youth Societies have been either initiated or at least encouraged by the
government. There are many other voluntary organizations where government
officials participate as observers or nonvoting members (e.g., Cultivation
Committees, Wew-sabhas, and Water Users' Associations).
The term "NGO" is used in this paper (and also in the Workshop) in the broad
sense of all the "voluntary bodies" working with or without government
involvement. This paper tries to briefly assess the NGO sector in Sri Lanka
and give a summarized account on the NGOs that have been involved in minor
irrigation improvement.
Historically, in Sri Lanka there have been informal religious and cultural
groups organized at the village level. The earliest formally organized NGOs
were started in the early 19th century with a religious, welfare, and
educational orientation.
At present a large number of "Grass Roots
Organizations" are functioning in the country. These are of different types
such as Rural Development Societies, Self-help groups, religious societies, Wewsabhas etc.
Most of these are self-financing and sometimes Grass Root
Organizations have been supported by the government and NGOs.
All in all, there,are about 150 nonlocal NGOs operating in the country,
according to a study done by Perera &d Samarasinghe ( 1988). Of these about 35
are international organizations each of which has an office in Sri M a . Some
of the Grass Root Organizations have been organized into more formal bodies with
the consensus of the government. Well-known examples are the Rural Development
Societies, which have been formalized under the Department of Rural Developnt,
and Youth Societies formed with the consensus of the Ministry of Youth Affairs.
Of the NGOs involved in agricultural and rural developnent, only a few have
a national-level structure, (e.g.,Sarvodaya, Mahila Samithi, and Federation of
Thrift and Credit Societies). In the Sri Lanka context the "Death Donation
Societies" have the reputation as the only local NCOs which do not receive any
support from a higher level (Government Organization or Nongovernment
Organization), and function quite effectively.
Finances and other facilities are available from many sources for NGOs and
Grass Root Organizations. However, not all the NGOs can fully utilize the
resources due to organizational weaknesses.
-
GOWRNMENT POLICY ON NGOs
Successive governments have increasingly realized the importance of NGOs,
as they could play a vital role in development and have a tremendous scope for
exrpansion. Although there has been no single policy declaration by the
government about the NGO sector other than the publication of the ruling party
11
--- page 20 ---
manifesto in October 1988, it is .clear from the government's interactions with
NOS, that the policy is one of noninterference and positive facilitation. It
is also evident that the government has accepted the view that NGOs have more
advantages than government organizations in working with and in reaching the
different groups of beneficiaries among the target population and that NCOs can
mobilize additional local resources. As mentioned earlier the government
actively encourages, through its own programs, the promotion of Grass Root
Organizations like Rural Development Societies, Women's Societies, Youth
Societies, Farmer Organizations, Self-help groups, etc.
Legal and
administrative provisions and procedures too have been devised for registration
of NGOs.
The present government's overall policy of relying on the private sector
and private initiative has served as the basis for the present policy on NGOs
and no restrictions are imposed on NGOs in obtaining foreign assistance. The
Ministry of Plan Implementation has been entrusted to coordinate and monitor
activities of foreign NGOs operating in the country. The government cooperates
closely with the NGOs, is well aware of the NGO programs, and appears to believe
that any attempts to control the NGOs would be counterproductive. At present
the government policy has explicitly provided a major developnent role for the
NGOs including its "Janasaviya" Poverty Alleviation Program, during the next six
years.
NGOS INVOLVED IN MINOR IRRIGATION
Of the nongovernmental organizations involved in minor irrigation, only a
few have irrigation rehabilitation 'or improvement programs, while the others
tend to play an indirect role providing supporting services. To keep a logical
sequence in the degree of involvement, the NGOs involved in minor irrigation are
divided into 3 categories: 1) directly involved in minor irrigation; 2 )
indirectly involved in minor irrigation; and 3 ) having future programs.
A brief note on each of these NGOs involved in minor irrigation improvement
is given in the following sections.
Sri Lanka National Freedom from Hunger Campaign Board. The FFHC is a
cooperation established by a government act in 1973 under the Ministry of
Agriculture with the objectives of securing aid from NGOs and using it for the
welfare and economic development of the country keeping in line with the
government programs. The FFHC is not an NGO by its origin but it functions as
an NGO and it receives financial assistance from several international
nongovernment bodies. Therefore we consider it as an N O . The FFHC has its
operations in 10 districts, including the wet zone, but its major involvements
are in the dry zone districts (e.g., Anuradhapura and Moneragala) and its work
depends solely upon human labor.
National Development Foundation. The Nationa? Development Foundation (NDF)
could be defined as a variant of the FFHC approach. The National Development
Foundation uses both manual labor and machinery for minor irrigation improvement
work.
It has minor irrigation projects in Kurunegala and Puttalam
Districts.
12
--- page 21 ---
Rural Development Societies... Rural Development Societies (RDSs) have
functioned as grassroots organizations from the early part of this century.
They have been active in organizing farmers for minor irrigation improvement
without any outside assistance aiming at agricultural development during the
pre-agrarian services period. From the late 1980s they have been allowed to
take various contracts under different government agencies, including the
Department of Agrarian Services and the Irrigation Department. They receive
priority in obtaining government contracts without tendering. However, at
present most of the Rural Development Societies are highly politicized,
resulting in mismanagementand deviation from their original objectives of rural
development.
In each village of Sri Lanka there is at least one Rural
Development Society at least in name.
Sarvodaya Shramadana Samithiya. Sarvodaya emerged to help people in
supporting themselves as a self-help (Shramadana) program. It has a more
cornanunity developnent rather than a physical development orientation. Their
overall program is geared to adjust the people's values and morale around
achieving common goals. Sarvodaya is the most prominent of the national level
NGOs with representation in about 5,000 of the country's 22,000 villages. Under
the Integrated Rural Development (IRD) program of Hambantota, the task of
community development in terms of organizing settled people into coherent groups
and developing assets (e.g., land, water etc.) was entrusted to Sarvodaya.
Federation of Thrift and Credit Cooperative Societies (ETCCS). The E"rccs
is a charity NGO geared to provide the rural poor with credit for different
social and economic needs. The societies are organized as cooperative societies
at the village level,'and the federation coordinates and monitors credit and
related activities. The FIy=cS helps in a wide range of economic activities such
as agriculture, small industries, self-employment, etc.
Participatory Institute for Development Alternatives (PIDA). The PIDA has
a strategy to change the process of developnent in favor of the disadvantageous
groups by means of supporting and strengthening people's organizations and
training group members in catalytic skills in stimulating such a process. The
PIDA operates in six districts at present.
CARE (Cooperative American Relief Everywhere). CAR33 is an international
NGO, which has very recently identified itself with a minor tank improvement
program in collaboration with the Department of Agrarian services. The program
is to improve village tank capacity by desilting them in three districts (viz.
Kurunegala, Puttalam, and Anuradhapura). The program w a s scheduled to cOmnenCe
in 1989.
PLAN International. PLAN too has identified itself with a small-scale
program for improving minor irrigation schemes in the mid-country starting 1989.
National Builders Association (NBA). The NBA has conducted some major
irrigation assistance programs in Nagadeepa Mahawewa Scheme (Badulla) and
Pimburettawa Scheme (Polonnaruwa)and it has now identified itself with a minor
irrigation project in the hill country to be initiated in 1989.
13
--- page 22 ---
Other KGOs: The other N O S involved in minor irrigation improvement are
the National Heritage Foundation (program in Kurunegala district ended in 19761,
the International Human Assistance Program (in Iiimbulwana), and Corrmunity Aid
Abroad (in Moneragala district).
14
--- page 23 ---
Role of Freedom From Hunger Campaign in the
Improvement of Minor Irrigation Systems in Sri Lanka
Dunstan Fernando
ORCZANIZATION
The Freedom From Hunger Campaign (F'FHC) is a public cooperation established
in 1973 under the Ministry of Agriculture.
Its development philosophy
emphasizes: a) people's participation and rural poverty alleviation; b)
promotion and encouragement of labor intensive projects;
c) changing chena cultivators into settled farmers by providing pe-ent
land
with facilities for irrigation; and d) assisting the poor people to enhance
their living standards.
The strategy adopted by the FFHC to achieve the aforesaid objectives insofar
as the minor irrigation systems are concerned has been renovation and
restoration of village tanks in the Dry Zone. The activities involved may be
divided into two categories: refurbishment of ancient tanks and rehabilitation
of abandoned tanks. Following a request from the village, a socioeconomic
survey is conducted by the FFHC which is followed by a feasibility study. On
the basis of these steps, a preliminary selection is made where availability of
land is also ensured. A tank bund/capacity survey will then be made and
clearance of the Department of Agrarian Services and the Irrigation Department
obtained. After going through these stages, Wew-sabhas will be formed and tank
renovation and restoration work will commence.
Instead of implementing a small tank renovation program of its own, the FFHC
enters into a partnership with the farmers using the means of storing water as
a focal point for rallying them into a Wew Sabha and then help these
organizations to plan and implement their own developnent programs. All
earthwork is done mually by the Wew Sabha members and their families. The
FFHC pays approximately US$1.30 (Rs 40) for 0.028 cubic meters(m3) (one cubic
foot) of earth which enables a family to earn abut US$23.00-33.00 (Rs 700-1000)
during the first three months.
The Wew-Sabha system is a familiar institution in the village comnunity as
it has been in existence over a long period of time. Traditionally, the system
has been formulated to collect revenue and also to ensure that each tank and its
15
--- page 24 ---
irrigation system was maintained in good working order. The Wew-Sabhas of the
present day are democratic organizations with annually elected office bearers
responsible for the maintenance of the tank and the irrigation system. It has
been designed to motivate the village community to discuss common problems and
to find ways and means to solve these problems by themselves. This will not
only ensure the improvement of their standard of living and quality of life, but
also promote self-reliance, leadership qualities and capacities in the village
youth
.
The main functions of the Wew-Sabha are: a) to function as a catalytic
organization; b) restoration work; c) repair and maintenance; d) regulation and
control of issue of water: el planning and regulation of cultivation pattern in
the irrigated areas; f) planning of and participation in village agriculture
development activities; and g ) planning of the participation in community
development and social welfare work.
As of June 1989, the FFHC has completed 135 tanks out of a target of 222
tanks. About 3,100 farm families are estimated to benefit fromthe village tank
rehabilitation program which will develop about 2509 ha (6,200 acres) of rice
and 1902 ha (4,700acres) of highland. The FFHC projects are financed by the
Swiss Inter Co-op7eration, the Swiss Inter Census, the FFHC Australia, Community
Aid Australia, and WELTHUNGERHILFE.
Out of 14 projects planned under the
program, 5 have been completed. Others are in progress.
Among the major constraints identified are: a) the lack of experienced
technical staff; b) the need for introducing new methods and techniques;
c) The need f o r flexibility in the FFHC management system; d) insufficiency of
funds; e) absence of a well-established maintenance fund; f) lack of
coordination with similar organizations; g) delays in communication between the
head office and the projects; and h) the need for decentralization of the FFHC
management system.
As a result of the village tank rehabilitation program the hitherto underutilized village resources such as land, water, labor, and other natural
resources such as animals, forests etc., have been put into better use. The
main lesson that has been learnt in the process relates to the need for
organization of village tank rehabilitation work simultaneously with comunitydevelopment work.
16
--- page 25 ---
Minor Irrigation Tank Renovation Projects
of the National Development Foundation
The National Development Foundation (NDF) established in 1979 is a nongovernmental organization registered under the Societies Ordinance of Sri Lanka
as a nonprofit voluntary agency.
The objectives of the National Development Foundation are:
1.
Build up villagers’ self confidence to handle their political,
economic, cultural, and social affairs by themselves.
2.
Help villagers to identify their resources and to mobilize them to
their advantage with least external help.
3.
Assist villagers in realizing their strength and power so that they
are able to know their rights and to demand them.
4.
Mobilize villagers at the grass-roots level with the help of change
agents to organize into groups to carry out developnent efforts in
rural areas.
The management council of the National Development Foundation (NDF) is the
supreme body which decides its policies, projects, and areas of development.
Four out of seven members selected mually for the management council are from
professionals for rural development and related fields. The other three are
coordinating committee members. The management council meets once in two months
to study the progress of various programs, to provide necessary guidelines and
to make decisions on the NDF activities.
The National Development Foundation has so far carried out six major
development programs excluding various other special projects.
1.
Water management and re-afforestation program supported by the
Australian Freedom From Hunger Campaign (AFFHC).
2.
Biogas and integrated farming projects with the help of the foundation
for International Training (Canada)and the Central Bank of S r i M a .
The Women’s Program was funded by the Canadian High Connnission, and at
present it is funded by the AFFHC.
17
--- page 26 ---
3.
The Buffalo Bank Project in Minipe settlement scheme with the
assistance of the Canadian High Commission.
4.
Integrated Village Development project in five villages with the
assistance of the AFFHC.
5.
Cottage Dairy Development Project with the help of the National
Livestock Board and National Banks.
6.
Renovation of minor tanks in Kurunegala and Puttalam districts with
the assistance of the AFFHC.
SI'RATEGY OF TANK RENOVATION FW"
A project planned out by the National Development Foundation (NDF), has
several activities.
1.
Renovate village tanks with the beneficiaries so that they develop some
sense of ownership over the tank and maintain it by themselves.
2.
Initiate and develop a suitable institutional arrangement which effects
a proper coordination system between farmers and government officials.
3.
Introduce modern agricultural techniques to small farmer groups.
4.
Train some local youth as change agents of agricultural development.
5.
Pave the way to organize informal educational programs for farmers.
The NDF started 16 selected minor irrigation renovation projects in
Kurunegala District in 1984. The criteria for selection of minor irrigation
systems are capacity of the tank, economic backwardness of the community which
depends on the tank, farmers' desire for external help to improve their
irrigation systems, lack of help from any other source to renovate the tank,
and the landownership pattern under the tank.
The NDF coordinators,prior to the renovation of a selected tank, reach the
farmers to carry out several preliminary investigations such as the
socioeconomic background of the farmers and technical aspects involved in the
renovation program.
First they meet individual farmer families and an effort is made to bring
them together for group discussions. Finally, farmers are influenced to
organize themselves as independent farmer societies. Once they are formed they
are compelled to contribute to the society fund. This process takes time, for
example in one renovated tank it took nine months to form the farmer society.
The socioeconomic survey helps the NDF coordinators to interact with farmer
groups freely. Once a report is submitted to them, farmers feel that their
problems are being addressed. With the farmers' participation the technical
survey is carried out by the Technical Assistants of the Agrarian Services
18
--- page 27 ---
Department. The farmers take part in the technical survey of tank bed,
catchment area, bund, and connnand area.
The collected data is tabulated and a report is prepared by the NDF
coordinators with the assistance of the youth selected under the tanks for
training as change agents. They help the farmers (society) to evaluate their
own situation and collectively discuss at the intervention stage. As a result
of this farmer participation in the technical survey, they know the capcity of
the tank, the quantity of water that has to be released to rice once renovated,
and how to maintain the catchment area.
These informal training programs for farmers have helped introduce an
effective water-management scheme under each tank. The farmers also appointed,
on their own, committees to implement water-management programs, downstreamdevelopment programs, catchment development, and forest-cover- conservation
programs. They also have organized their own farmer fund to which they
contribute 10.4 to 20.87 kg ( 1 / 2 to 1 bushel) of unmilled rice or their
equivalent.
Farmer societies together with the NDF coordinator request the Technical
Officer of the Department of Agrarian Services to visit the tank and conduct
the surveys on the tank bund, tank bed, and connnand area, and on other relevant
technical aspects. Once these surveys are over, a ratification meeting is held
with the farmers and the Technical Officers after which a project proposal is
drawn up and submitted to the international organizations for possible funding
through the National Development Foundation Head Office. Once the project is
approved it is notified to farmer organizations and with the assistance of the
Technical Officers of the Agrarian Services Department, final estimates and
plans are drawn up for renovation activities. These plans are then discussed
with farmer groups to make them understand the technical aspects of the project.
The National Development Foundation looks forward to continue this program
in the d r y zone of Sri Lanka and to share their exprierices with NGOs and other
state institutions in the future.
The first project implemented in Kurunegala district included 10 village
The total number of farm families benefited by this project is 172.
Farmer organizations were fonned for each tank and together they contributed
over US$3330 (Rs 100,000) both in cash and kind for the renovation whilst the
NDF spent US$40,000 (Rs 1.2 million). The estimated government contribution in
terms of services etc., is around US$lO,OOO (Rs 300,000).
tanks.
19
--- page 28 ---
FFHC and NDF in the Renovation of Village Irrigation Schemes:
Some Comparisons and Contrasts in the Planning Concepts
Kapila P. Vimaladharma.
It was only in 1988 that Dr. Jayantha Perera presented a brief assessment
of the National Development Foundation (NDF) approach to village tank renovation
as compared to the Freedom From Hunger Campaign (FFHC) approach. The comparison
was based on the findings of his appraisal of the National Development
Foundation's tank renovation program in Kurunegala District (Perera, 1 9 8 7 ) ' and
an appraisal of a similar program of rehabilitation of scattered villagereservoir cornunities in Anuradhapura by the FFHC (Perera: 1 9 8 7 ) .
In summary, Dr. Perera noted the following points:
1.
Whilst the NDF is an NGO the FFHC is a statutory body; the former
having a flexibility that the latter cannot have.
2.
The NDF is eclectic in selecting tank corrnnunities since it does not
specify a minimum and a maximum number of beneficiary households as
a selection criterion whilst the FE'HC insisted on a minimum of 25
households thus limiting the latter's scope.
3.
Both agencies have similar objectives although the FFHC additionally
placed emphasis on land consolidation and land redistribution.
4.
Both believed in a "nonregimented intervention style" and both
encouraged the initiatives of the communities though the NDF was more
successful in ensuring cornrmnity participation and self-management.
5.
Both had mobilized the communities "labor" (at only half the wage rate)
and some cash for construction and maintenance work; for management
purposes, the beneficiaries were organized into their own
associations.
6.
The FFHC attempted to resuscitate traditional agricultural practices
whilst the NDF encouraged integrated farming systems and other incomegenerating activities.
In this short presentation the ruling concepts and methods in project
planning adoptedby the two agencies are dealt with in relation to the different
strategies of field implementation. An attempt is being made to compare the
NDF's Kurunegala program with the FFHC's Siyambalanduwa program in the
Moneragala District.
20
--- page 29 ---
Perhaps it is unfair to compare the FFHC's resettlement-oriented irrigation
program at Si;vamhalanduwa with the tank-renovation program of the NDF, First,
the objectives of the two programs are different, and hence the strategies too
tend to be varied. More importantly, the political climate and security
situation in the Siymbalanduwa were not conducive to field work by the FFHC
staff, and this led to delays and disappointments in achieving project outputs
and farmer participation.
The NDF tried chiefly to increase the productivity of lands already
cultivated, though haphazardly, under the renovated tanks. If there were any
additional extents brought under the plough as a result of increased tank
capacity or due to saving of irrigation water, the increment was only marginal.
(XI the other hand, in Si;vambalanduwa what is attempted is a far-reaching
land reform coupled with a technological quantum jump; hitherto landless,
scatt>ered,encroacher families eking out an existence from chena cultivation
w e r e brought together in a planned nucleated settlement and each family provided
with three separate allotments earmarked as a home lot, for rain-fed cropping
and for irrigated rice. The rice lands were reclaimed from pittani lands (lands
left fallow after swidden cultivation and have become meadows) and are irrigated
from a newly constructed or renovated small reservoir. The transition from
chena-cropping (swidden cultivation) to settled irrigated rice culture and cashcropping indeed demands a substantial technological adaptation on the part of
the beneficiary settler-farmers and innovative action on the part of the
officials.
Controlled irrigation, rice culture itself, use of purchased inputs, and
collective actions were all hitherto unknown to the majority of the former
chena-farmers. Land development, consolidation of holdings and redistribution
of allotments, therefore were crucial objectives of the FFHC's irrigation
schemes in Siyambalanduwa. Thus, for the FFHC, the challenge was much greater
and results more likely to be delayed and difficult than for the NDF. The
latter had the advantage of having to work with long-established ricecultivating communities. In this context the varying experiences of the two
agencies do not lend themselves to simple comparison and perhaps such an attempt
would be misplaced energy.
The outline of the strategy of mobilizing beneficiaries' labor and their
participation in construction and operation and maintenance of the irrigation
system is about the same for both the FFHC and the NDF, though there are notable
differences in its implementation by the two agencies.
Most of the shortcomings of the FFHC would flow from its somewhat rigid
adherence to what can be called a blueprint. It means that the objectives and
the strategies of the FFHC's irrigation-cum-resettlementprojects are invariably
fixed beforehand and that too at the headquarters. The ecological "fix" that
chenairg (swidden-cultivation)is deleterious is something that is debatable.
27
--- page 30 ---
misperception of rchat is taken to be chenaing can be seen in the
Siy-amhalandwmpro.ject. The farmers themselves call their enterprise a pittani
cultivation for by now there is no prime forest land easily available for the
practice of traditional chena. The farmers return to the same plot allowing
only a very short fallow cycle of about 2-3 years by which time what was once
a chena has become a pittani (meadow)and not a .jungle.
A
We have observed in the field a few (perhaps rich) pittani cultivators
ploughing with tractors, using chemical fertilizers and pesticides, and
cultivating high-value cash crops (e.g.,pumpkins) for the market. Such fanners
defy the known definition of chena (swidden) farmers. Even after becoming
members of the FFHC Tank Association, and thus becoming the target beneficiaries
of the FFHC program, they are reluctant to give up pittani cultivation. For
them, pittani give the cash crops and the new rice fields provide their
subsistence food crop. This view is at sharp variance with that of the National
Development Foundation. It further illustrates the planning problem associated
with any blueprinted developent philosophy and its associated strategy.
The concept of the model village which inspired the Freedom From Hunger
Campaign program (Ratnatunga 1982) was one derived from a romanticized version
of an ici,,llic Sinhala dry-zone village; a village republic in which there was
said to be ecological balance, self-management, self-sufficiency, and high
social cohesion. Such a static "village in the jungle'' if ever it existed is,
i n any case, a rarity today and it has rightly been noted that "The ideal
picture of villagers living in perfect harmony is a figment of the imagination"
(Howes 1983 p . 1 6 ) . It is not surprising that today's rural people would, in
fact, resist the recreation of such a model. Planning for its resuscitation,
has inevitably become a topdown imposition.
In the implementation of a blueprinted strategy the scope for beneficiary
participation becomes restricted from the beginning. Participation is perceived
merely as contribution of labor for construction works. Such a view disregards
the community's felt needs and its innate capcity to think and prepare what its
members perceive as important and relevant. It also puts a premium on the time
and efforts of the field staff in their constant attempts to direct, control and
keep the flock on the right path. Innovative thinking on their part tends to
be discouraged. Motivating and training the implementing officials also becomes
difficult, and is further aggravated when the training itself flows from another
blueprint which takes no cognizance of alternative methods as well as client and
locale spcific sociocultural differences.
In contrast, the NDF has adopted an open, pragmatic, and flexible approach
in deciding on the type of project. The NDF lets the community decide the
project it wants. It only helps technically and organizationally to perceive,
plan, and implement the project that the community has agreed is best for them.
The NDF therefore has no ''model." Its charismatic leadership and closeness to
the rural people who are of diverse circumstances are factors that would
discourage the tendency to build one's own National Development Foundation
model.
22
--- page 31 ---
Eking a resettlement pro.ject, the Freedom From Hunger Campaign (FFHC)
conceived it as a comprehensive one encompassing technical, social, and
organizational aspects. That perspective tends to make the pro.ject authority
assume responsibility and to direct all activities in the belief that the other
officials who are considered as too bureaucratic and not well motivated might
even pollute the concept of the tank-based cormunity that the FFHC was trying
to promote. The involvement of and coordination with other governmental and “
I
bodies in the area b e c o m e restricted. This w a s evident in the Siyamhlanduwa
pro.ject in the early stages where the project was isolated from the other
institutions whose intervention was even resented. On the other hand, the FFHC
itself did not have the expertise and experience within itself, in settlement
planning, agricultural extension, and agrarian change. The situation became
mrst for the beneficiary farmers, the wew-sabha members, who found themselves
falling between two stools.
hiat happened in Siyambalanduwa in maha 1987/88 might illustrate this point.
The agricultural extension which would usually be provided by the officials of
the Department of Agriculture under its normal programs was not forthcoming
because the project was considered a special one outside the scope of the
department. The services of the Agrarian Services Officers of the area, e.g.,
Agro-identity cards, kanna meetings, estimates of inputs, and arrangements for
their supply were not available to the Siyamhalanduwa FFHC farmers. The FFHC’s
own attempts to provide seed and credit in time were not synchronized with the
In these
agriculture calendar which was itself not properly drawn up.
circumstances the farmers rely on their own resourcefulness; some borrowed seed
rice from friends; a few who were members of the Cooperative Thrift Society which
had been there before the FFHC project managed to get credit from it and in the
process to revive it; some approached extension officers and knowledgeable
farmers and obtained advice on an individual basis; they devised their own watermanagement system. In four of the renovated tanks most of the farmers did some
rice cultivation which was their first-ever cultivation. The ill-effects of the
isolation of the FFHC projects from the normal agrarian administration and
agricultural extension system was brought to the notice of the FFHC authorities
who have since then tried to seek out and coordinate the Sipmbalanduwa-project
activities with other agencies in the area.
On the other hand, the National Development Foundation (NDF) has from the
beginning mobilized the services of the government agencies in the area. In
fact, the field investigations and surveys, estimates, and designs for the NDF
tanks were prepared by the Technical Officer of the Agrarian Services and
extension work done by the officials of the Department of Agriculture. Close
links are established with the Assistant Government Agent of the area and the
banks. The NDF was able to bring its renovated tanks within the normal field
programs of the other departments, The farmers have learnt a lot from these
officers and from their own collective experiences and are quite confident of
their own ability to sustain the renovated systems.
23
--- page 32 ---
Two other FFHC resettlement-cum-irrigation projects which were completed
earlier were the Tanthirimale and the Wagurumale projects. These two programs
have been found to be successful (Richards 1983; Howes 1984). The unfavorable
security situation was responsible for the shortcomings in the Siyambalanduwa
project. However, the argument in this paper is that the planning concept itself
constricted the strategies and styles of field implementation.
One measure with xhich to assess the result of the two approaches is to look
at the unit cost. In the Kurunegala projects the NDF has recorded a per tank
cost of approximately US$3,807 (Rs 114,200)whilst the FFHC in the Anuradhapura
program has spent US$7,167 ( R s 215,000)per tank (Perera 1988, p.22; Perera 1987,
p.12). Admittedly, the above figures are too gross for a comparison. In any
case the Sipmbalanduwa costs may be even higher because of the additional costs
of resettlement which the Anuradhapura projects did not carry.
Also, it is too early to come to conclusions about the Siyambalanduwa
projects because the majority of them are not yet completed. However, the
present management is aware of the need to be dynamic and client-responsive in
planning and implementation. Though it is saddled with an inherited concept
the need for innovative thinking action is not ruled out.
24
--- page 33 ---
Role of Rural Development Societies in the Improvement
of Minor Irrigation Systems
G.K.G. Perera
ORGANIZATION
Rural development as a government activity was first started in 1940 under
the Department of Commerce and Industry. Under this scheme Rural Development
Officers were posted to villages where rural development service centers were
established. The main idea was to develop the village on a self-help basis.
In 1948, a separate department was established for rural development, and in
1951, ten Provincial Training Centers were set up to train the office bearers
and members of Rural Development Societies in community development. In 1952,
the department initiated women’s rural development societies and in 1954, they
were given assistance from the departmental funds. In the following year, the
Department of Rural Development was amalgamated with the Department of Cottage
Industries. Once again in 1970, a separate department was created for Rural
Development. In 1978, a separate ministry was formed for Rural Development and
recently it, was brought under the purview of provincial administration.
Rehabilitation of old village tanks and improvement of minor irrigation
works were undertaken by Rural Development Societies for which assistance from
the World Food F’rograrmne was obtained. Labor-intensive methods were employed
in this connection and aid under the World Food Programme used as an incentive
for voluntary work done by villagers. Under this project 6,000 tanks in the
d r y zone and 5,000 minor irrigation schemes in the wet zone were to be
rehabilitated using 11,200,000 man days. A total of 13.6 m3 (480 cubic feet)
of earthwork and 13.9 m2 ( 150 square feet) of turfing were to be performed.
The implementation strategy included the Government Agent as the central
executing authority at the district level assisted by field staff of the
Department of Rural Development. The Rural Development Society, as the villagelevel organization, organized work in the village.
EXPERIENCE
The work commenced in 1972 and the performance during the first six months
exceeded the target. However, it slowed down since then due to drought and the
project activities were subsequently suspended. A new project which also
included tank rehabilitation was implemented in the drought-stricken areas.
25
--- page 34 ---
The original project after 4 years of operation had achieved only 51 percent of
the target and had utilized only 40 percent of the food aid. The project was
extended by one year and was reformulated as the National Shramadana Programme.
Consequently, the activities were accelerated during the first six months.
However, the cyclone of 19’78 affected the progress. As an emergency operation
a post-cyclone rehabilitation program was conducted and the World Food Programme
agreed to another one-year extension.
An Interior Evaluation Commission reported 86 percent of target achievement
and observed that the schemes in the wet zone were too small and that they could
do without World Food Programme assistance. It further noted that hardly any
technological support had been provided either in the formulation or
implementation of tank-rehabilitation programs despite the involvement of the
Assistant Government Agent.
At the end of March 1981 when the project
terminated, 4,102 village tanks and 2,925 minor irrigation tanks had been
completed using 11,697,541 man days.
Although the overall responsibility for the implementation of this project
rested with the Department of Rural Development the Government Agents at the
district level were responsible for the selection of the schemes, designing,
estimation of man days, and distribution of the World Food Programme’s food
commodities. Technical assistance w a s supposed to be provided by the technical
departments such as the Irrigation Department. However, as the Evaluation
Mission has reported the Government Agents failed to consult and to receive
technical advice from the related technical agencies. Frequently the provision
of the structures such as spillways, outlet pipes, etc., was not made in time
by the Irrigation Department, and i n some instances, the financing process for
such structures was initiated only after the earthworks were completed b%ich led
to long delays in the installation of the required structures. This meant long
delays for the completed earthworks to be used by the farmers and frequently it
led to deterioration of the completed earthworks even before they were put to
use by the community.
26
--- page 35 ---
Discussion
In the discussion that followed,Mr. Joe Alwis the chairperson of the session
observed #at the nature and the role of the NGOs have been romanticized to some
extent and highlighted the tendency of the NCOG to disappear after a short period
which he described as a "characteristic
drawback." Noting the flexible style of the management of the NGOs, he raised
two crucial questions:
1.
2.
In what ways can the NGOs be mobilized for maximum effectiveness?
Are we looking at the sustainability of the NGOS or the minor irrigation
schemes?
According to Dr. Douglas J. Merrey it is not too difficult to stimulate the
farmer, but the real question relates to the next logical step after a group of
people has been motivated.
M r . D.G. Dayaratne claimed that the farmer
organizations are not sustainable and that the assumption that once farmers have
been motivated they will go on their own is invalid. According to M r . U.
Magedaragamage the role of the NGOs is to get the farmers to interact and develop
their own skills. In his opinion, the role of the NGOs should be that of
facilitator only. The stimulation can be sustained provided the NGOs are able
to secure fanners' involvement, boost self-confidence, and inculcate a sense of
ownership. The NGOS should not stop at tank rehabilitation. They should g o
beyond that and help the farmers to start other projects. It is essential that
the fanners learn to generate their own funds and resources.
M r . Joe Alwis responded with another series of questions relating to source
of funds, the connnand area of the tank, the relationship with the government
officials, the definitions of irrigation schemes, and the perceived role of the
National Development Foundation. M r . Magedaragamage replied that: a) the
National Development Foundation is funded mainly by Australian Assistance; b)
the tank capacity varies; c ) the Department of Agrarian Services provides free
technicalassistance; andd) the NationalDevelopment Foundationbears additional
costs of food, transport etc. He added that because of the barriers between the
farmers and the officials for meaningful dialogue to developnent the government
officials cannot organize farmers effectively, and therefore that the question
of training government officials to do the work of NGOs does not arise. Dr.
Panabokke observed that it is not fair to expect NGOs to answer the question of
sustainability by themselves alone as it is a complex question puzzling all the
social scientists. M r . Jaliya Medagama stated that the Department of Agrarian
Services has rehabilitated a large number of tanks, has held a number of useful
training programs, arid has identified various management problems.
Mr. Magedaragamage replying to another question by M r . Alwis stated that it
is important not to promise anything at the outset but to familiarize with the
27
--- page 36 ---
situation, with the people including the women, before talking about tanks and
cultivation. M r liapila 1:imaladharma observed that farmers’ involvement,
effective training, efficient organization, and adequate funds are crucial for
a project to be successful. The Australian counterpart of the National
Development Foundation informed that their organization has a time frame of
three years after the commencement of the project f o r withdrawing from the
community-. Dr. Merreg questioned the rationale of the hea\T dependence of farmer
trr-lining and involvement in relation to sustainability. In his opinion, the
sustainability depends on the availability of funds and government assistance.
Mr. Joe Alwis countered that no matter what resources are available planning is
all-important and the smooth and efficient working of the bureaucracy would
contribute to the sustainability in a ma.jor w a y . It is necessary to know the
boundaries of government involvement in NGO work. Some kind of guidelines will
have to be developed in connection with each aspect of the project. M r .
Wickramasinghe observed that given the specific circumstances and the
socioeconomic factors one should not be too heavily weighed in favor of
replication.
.
28
--- page 37 ---
Role of Sarvodaya in the Improvement of Minor Irrigation Systems
sama Gunawardhana
ORGANIZATION
Sarvodaya the largest NGO in Sri M a w a s fonned in 1958. It is funded by
About
international donors ( the Netherlands, Germany, France, USA, and UK)
500 villagers actively participate in Sarvodaya activities. The philosophy of
Sarvodaya views poverty as a manifestation of the inability of the individuals
to satisfy basic needs. It has identified 10 integrated basic needs as being
fundamental to individual and village awakening;environment, housing, education,
water, health care, clothing, communication, food, fuel, and spiritual and
cultural needs. It believes that the present communities located in remote areas
are denied institutional services and attempts to fill this vacuum by providing
the services directly through its own agencies and where necessary with
coordination between the village and line agencies.
.
Sarvodaya work is organized at five levels: The Village; the Shramadana
Division (a cluster of five villages); the Sarvodaya Division (four clusters);
District; and the Region.
SEIJECrIoN CRITERIA
The first step in the selection of a project is the preliminary survey
conducted by the Sarvodaya m a 1 Technical Services Division (SRTSD)where the
relevant d a t a are collected and estimates are prepared. In the process of doing
so the villagers are oriented to the proposed project and necessary technical
skills are passed through. A technical survey would be carried out if the survey
determines that the project: a) is outside the responsibility of irrigation
development; b) is feasible; c) serves economic objectives;
d) serves social objectives; e) utilizes local skills and resources; and f) is
economically viable. The project is then offered to the donor agencies and if
the project is approved the SFtTSD conducts a social and economic analysis. The
funds approved by the donor are channeled through the Sarvodaya Shramadana
Sangamay-a ( SSS )
.
STRATEGY
Shramadana or collective voluntary work is the driving force of the SSS at
all levels. On receipt of the request by the village to join the SSS a team of
Sarvodaya volunteers visits the village for a briefing which is aimed at creating
a sense of awareness. On confirmation of the villagers' willingness to subscribe
29
--- page 38 ---
to Sarvodaya an inaugural Shramadana Camp lasting about a week is organized.
Here the village is treated as a single family which is the concept rationalized
in the development process. At the conclusion of the inaugural Shramadana Camp
functional leaders are chosenandthe essential infrastructure consisting of five
elements, namely, Singithi (preschool),
& (mothers1 , Yowun (youth), Govi (farmers), and Smudan (shramadana) is
organized in haulas (groups). The activities of these haulas or gatherings are
coordinated by the Shramadana Samithiya. The center provides a series of
essential services such as education, health, water, credit for housing,
vocational training etc., through several agencies and where necessary the
Shramadana Samithiya is mobilized to provide labor.
SARVODAYA IRRIGATION-DEV'EIBRIEN" PEE0JM;Ts
Killinochchi farm. The project was funded by HELVITAS of Switzerland at
an estimated cost of Rs 500,000. Extending over an area of about 12 ha the
project involved the construction of an irrigation canal from I d u w a tank
to the farm and the development of an on-farm surface-irrigation system for the
benefit of the people who had migrated from plantations.
Puttalam farm and Anumdhapura farm. The main system w a s made up of a
network of ferro-cement canals and several pumping systems to lift water from
the wells to be fed into the network from which the waste water was siphoned
into the terraces. Horizontal wells were also dug up to increase the water
yield. All these farms were designed to provide training on farming systems,
extension, and livestock management with a strong emphasis in the management of
the ecosystem, agro-forestry, and appropriate technology.
Thanamalwila farm. Funded by NOVIB of Netherlands, this farm has three
tanks providing supplementary irrigation to about 20.2 ha ( 5 0 acres) of rice in
maha and abut 8 . 1 ha (20 acres) in yala. A n additional 8 . 1 ha (20 acres) are
During the
irrigated through a lift-irrigation system from Kirindioya.
construction phase, 100 volunteers received practical experience in tank
rehabilitation, construction, and infrastructure development. This farm aims
at developing a rice-centered farming system. Experience has demonstratedthat
the success of this system is dependent on the seed bed being ready for planting
by mid-October, the latest, and planting being completed by the third week so
that the crop could be brought in by February to allow enough lead time for the
yala program.
Tank-based community development under HIRDP. The Norwegian Agency for
International Development (NORAD) assisted a community development program under
"Rehabilitated Tank-Based Settlement Project" of Hambantota Integrated Rural
Development Program (HIRDP) starting in 1981. Three clusters of settlements,
namely, Weliwewa, Mattala, and Gonnoruwa consisting of a total of 18 tanks were
developed by HIRDP; and Sarvodaya was requested to organize farmers to receive
the expcted benefits. The NORAD assisted Sarvodaya to establish its communitydevelopnent work in almost all of these tank-settlements. The movement helped
farmers to organize themselves for downstream development, marketing, etc.
30
--- page 39 ---
CONCLUSION
Sarvodaya involvement in irrigation management has been very limited due to
the diversity of its concerns, which are within the broad area of village
development. The main thrust has been on mobilization of labor on Shramadana
basis.
31
--- page 40 ---
NGOs as Facilitators in Minor Irrigation Development:
A Case Study from Hambantota District, Sri Lanka
Inge Jungeling
ASSISTING MINOR IRRIGATION SYSTEMS
In Sri Lanka, there is a contradiction between the diversity in minor
irrigation systems and the rigidity of the government programs that aim to
increase agricultural productivity under these systems. Minor irrigation systems
show a great variety in the fields of assistance to these programs, the use of
the physical system, and the way water management is pursued. This variety is
basically expressed by the different interests of water users in one minor
irrigation system compared to other minor irrigation systems (because of
agronomic features, location of the system in a chain of small systems, and
possibilities for marketing of irrigated crops in a certain location), and by
the different interests of water users within one system (because of labor
availability, other employment opportunities, and individual networks).
The programs aim to facilitate a more controlled irrigation management as
this would lead to a more efficient water use and thus to more prospects for
higher yields. Such a controlled irrigation management is only sustainable if
it is supported by the water users; and because the innovations introduced (which
are basically the same for every system under these programs and which are based
on the Walagambahu model) often do not suit the interests of water users the
results of the programs have been meager.
The consequence of these meager results was (as happened in Hambtota
District) that often more responsibilities in irrigation management were assigned
to the field-level officers of the Department of Agrarian Services, to provide
more facilities to the water users (e.g., cultivation loans) and to promote
discipline among the water users. Interaction between the officers and the water
users had to be pursued through a farmer representative but the (theoretical)
legal authority remained in the hands of the Department of Agrarian Services.
Although the results measured in agricultural productivity may be good in some
systems, in general, such a program is not sustainable from the points of view
of quality control and cost effectiveness. The field-level officer may not be
able to cover the interests of the water users and will not be able to monitor
the system constantly as he has more systems to visit and many other duties to
perform. If these irrigation-management responsibilities are to be applied in
all minor irrigation systems as is the current intent, the staffing intensity
and the budget of the department would have to increase dramatically.
Consequently, irrigation-management responsibilities should be as much as
possible in the hands of the water users and they themselves should decide
whether more controlled water management is a profitable affair, considering
their own interests. Theoretically, this means that water users should create
a demand for improvement of their system and that the Department of Agrarian
32
--- page 41 ---
Services should consider this demand and may respond with a flexible service
supply ( e . g . , assisting in repairs or construction of physical structures, and
assisting in the design of appropriate time tables). Also, water users should
bear as much of the costs of the assistance as possible to enhance their longterm commitment to the system and for the Department to maintain costeffectiveness.
Yet, water users may not know about the possible services that might be
delivered to them and may not be able to cooperate in a way that a sustainable
demand is created. The Department of Agrarian Services, on the other hand, is
not. well-geared to engage in a complicated and time-consuming communication
process with water users, especially when it has to concentrate on the ways to
meet technical demands of water users (Jiggins and Roling, 1982). Hence a
facilitator is necessary.
WHAT CAN BE EXPECTED OF NGOS?
The major NGOs active in minor irrigation development provide their
assistance either directly to groups of water users with the help of field
officers employed by the NGO ( e . g , the National Development Foundation, the Sri
Lanka Freedom From Hunger Campaign, and the Nation Builders’ Association), or
indirectly through village-level societies supported by that organization (e.g.,
Sarvodaya Shramadana Societies,Rural Development Societies and the Youth Clubs).
The organizations of the last group are often government departments and the
societies are often existing organizations that are sometimes used to improve
small irrigation systems. In all cases the village-level activities are guided
by a higher-level organization or umbrella organization. Some NGOs provide the
technical support themselves as part of their program, while other N O S envisage
to obtain technical support from the Department of Agrarian Services (or from
the Irrigation Department). Here we are concerned with the NGOs that mediate
between water users and technical supporting agencies.
Whether an NGO is suitable to fill the gap between technical support in
minor irrigation development and the need to respond to local interests depends
on the actual objectives of the NGO, its approach in practice, and the field of
decision making the NGO is asked and be able to participate in. In line with
the abovementioned considerations actual objectives should be to evoke a longterm commitment of water users to a system and to assist in matching the
different interests within the system with a strategyto improve the performance
of the system and the required resource mobilization. In its approach the NGO
should focus on a clear target group, the persons who have an interest in the
system and on facilitating an autonomous decision- making process pursued by the
water users, whereby the different interests are adequately considered (e.g.,
in addition to the interests of the direct water users, the interests of
landowners who do not cultivate the land, of fishermen who use the tank, and of
politicians). Such an approach will vary according to different locations.
The fields of decision making in which the NGO is able to operate and allowed
to do so depend on the relations between the NGO and other supporting
organizations (e.g., technical-support agencies like the Department of Agrarian
Services and donors, and institutional support agencies like the Planning Unit
in the Integrated Rural Development Programs).
33
--- page 42 ---
Not all NGOs involved in minor irrigation improvement are in themselves
suitable institutions to enhance such a process: in Sri Lanka many government
agencies supporting village-level organizations provide their services on the
basis of supply rather than demand to members of the societies who are not
necessarily water users only. This dilutes the required commitment of the water
users to a system. Furthermore, some NGOs suffer from the project- specific
nature of their involvement: the envisaged budget has to be spent regardless of
the commitment of the beneficiaries. On the other hand, many water users have
discover& the benefit of mobilizing such funds for their own goals (e.g,,some
cash income) which do not necessarily relate to improved irrigation management.
Although the involvement of NGOs in minor irrigation development in Sri
Lanka has been successful in a number of cases in Hambantota District this
involvement has not been very fortunate. Here the Sarvodaya Shramadana Movement
(Sarvodaya) has been participating in a tank-rehabilitation project under the
Norwegian (NORAD)fundedHambantota IntegratedRural Development Program (HIRDP).
The project started in 1979. At the inception of the connnand area (of 18 tanks)
the project providedthe beneficiaries with a complex of facilities ranging from
public facilities (schools and health centers) on a cluster basis to assistance
in putting up houses, and to assistance in the development of both the irrigated
and the dry land. While the facilities were basically provided without
consulting the beneficiaries’ (Leelasena, 1 9 8 7 ) , the HIRDP recognized that
beneficiaries’ participation would be instrumental to successful project
implementation especially when regarding irrigation management. In 1981, the
NORAD contracted Sarvodaya to address this issue in the project area. In part
of the project area Sarvodaya is still continuing its assistance.
Sarvodaya’s main contribution to irrigation management in a number of tanks
was its initiation of communal work camps for repairs to these tanks. Yet, such
work camps were not continued on a regular basis (e.g,, annually). In later
stages of the project Sarvodaya shifted its attention to welfare aspects of
community development (e.g., housing and preschools). The involvement of
Sarvodaya can be seen as a complex of decision-making processes conditioned by:
a) the contributions of the project-supporting agencies;
b) the actual objectives of Sarvodaya; and c) its approach in practice.
Accordingly, a number of shortcomings can be recognized:
* N O W and HIRDP never made clear what they actually expected of Sarvodaya
and therefore did not translate vague expectations into concrete programs.
This had two important consequences. First, it was difficult to give
concrete support to Sarvodaya when it was not made clear what activities
had to be carried out. Second, it was easy to change expectations when
current activities appeared to be poorly performed, but still without
creating the necessary conditions to achieve expectations. Sarvodaya from
its side rejected too much external interference; it was convinced that
its approach would be an asset to the project and was therefore not very
open to discussions on the contents of its involvement. Here, it should
be noted that the project started at a time when both HIRDP and Sarvodaya
had to build up institutional capacity (and their approach) in the area.
34
--- page 43 ---
* There was no technical line agency that could support Sarvodaya in its
activities. The Department of Agrarian Services started operating in the
project area in 1984. It required a lot of effort from the HIRDP to assist
and guide the Department in increasing its operational capacity, in
general, and in performing its duties in the project area, in particular.
The involvement of Sarvodaya in this would have been an extra burden
because by that time Sarvodam was proven not to be very successful in its
irrigation- management activities.
X
Since the beginning of the project evoking the comitment of the
beneficiaries has not been a project strategy; it was assumed that the
water users would use the facilities provided as envisaged. It is hard
to reverse this process since Sarvodaya became involved in the project at
a later stage. In addition, a number of tanks ex-perienced severe water
problems (even when rainfall was sufficient) limiting the possibilities
for Sanwdaya to be involved in irrigation management.
* The Sarvodaya approach, however admirable its goals are, was not very
suitable to assist water users in improving irrigation management.
Sarvodaya did not recognize a specific target group: all villagers within
their area of attention were allowed to participate in the activities
initiated by Sarvodaya. A broad awareness of the advantages of comunal
efforts was assumed to have its positive effects on irrigation management
as well. The comunal camps for repairs to tanks were more valued for
their attendance by outsiders than for its effects on long-term maintenance
capacity of the system. Furthermore, Sarvodaya provided its servi,ceson
the basis of supply rather than of demand. Although many of the facilities
provided did not have a direct relation to irrigation management (e.g.,
assistance in putting up houses, latrines, wells, and community centers)
it had its effects on the way Sarvodaya was perceived by the project
beneficiaries. The role of the community workers who were staying in the
project area has been minimal and they were too little informed about the
project itself and about requirements of irrigation management for an
adequate involvement in irrigation management.
Although expectations might not have been fulfilled completely it is beyond
doubt that it was, in principle, a good idea to involve an intermediate
organization to work with the project beneficiaries. As was foreseen at the
inception of the project the HIRDP and other supporting government agencies
would not have been able to obtain the commitment of the project beneficiaries
by themselves, given their current set-ups.
Any involvement of NGOs in such development programs needs careful
consideration abut what the N O is supposed to initiate, how the objectives
and the approach of the NGO suit the strategy of the program, and what is
expected from supporting agencies. If the intervention process is managed by
an organization separate from the NGO itself (e.g., HIRDP), that organization
should be responsible for ensuring that the strategies of the different actors
(water users, NGOs, and agencies involved) are compatible with the end results
35
--- page 44 ---
envisaged. This leads us back to the concern about h a t is expected from water
users in t e r m s of comnitment, resource mobilization, and actual responsibilities
in irrigation management and what (flexible) service delivery can be expected
from the Department of Agrarian Services over the long term (and not on a project
basis). There is a need to clarify this complex of responsibilities in the first
place.
36
--- page 45 ---
Role of Participatory Institute for Development Alternatives
in the Improvement of Minor Irrigation Systems
S.P. Wickramamchchi
ORGANIZATION
The general objectives of the Participatory Institute for Development
Alternatives (PIDA) are: a) to initiate and participate in development action
aimed at changing the process of development in favor of the economically and
socially disadvantaged groups; b) to support and strengthen people’s
organizations; and c) to organize training in catalytic skills for participatory
and self-reliant development processes. Established in 1981, the PIDA currently
has 15 researchers who operate as catalytic interveners in selected locations
in 6 districts, namely, Hambantota, Matara, Galle, Colombo, Anuradhapura, and
Ihndy.
The Participatory Institute for Development Alternatives views village
society as having a fundamental contradiction between a minority of dominant
interests and the majority living in poverty. The relationship between these
groups is often asymmetrical with the rich minority being able to control the
very survival of the poor. As a result, a considerable portion of the production
value of the small producer gets into the hands of the dominant interest group
through low prices paid for produce, high prices charged for inputs, high land
rents, and corruption of various sorts.
This process leaves the poor
impoverished and suppresses the rural productive forces and keeps the
productivity at a low level. It also further intensifies and consolidates
dependency structures of the village.
Moreover, the poor are divided on the basis of caste, religion, and other
factors. The dependency attitudes and the lack of unity among them inhibit the
poor from taking an initiative to improve their lot andmake them non-innovative
and non-experimental. This explains why it is difficult, if not impossible, for
self-reliant rural development action to emerge spontaneously, on the one hand
and why catalytic intervention is more often than not a necessary initial input
to stimulate the poor for self-reliant action, on the other.
The PIDA strategy differs from other techniques of intervention adopted by
governmental or nongovernmental organizations in that the PIDA intervention
identifies the poorer sections of the village society and stimulates them for
group action to investigate, analyze, and change the reality of the village
situation, not on the basis of a neutral or a technocratic approach. It is a
37
--- page 46 ---
process of scientific inquiry into poverty by the poor themselves which results
in a social awareness leading to a change in the fatalistic beliefs and in a
search for action that the poor could themselves undertake to counter the
impoverishment process. They begin to realize their own collective power to
retain the surplus of their production and protect it from exploiters and use
it for their own consumption and investment and with each group action they
consolidate themselves and enhance the collective fund which is expended to the
group’s advantage. In this process they improve their access to resources on
the one hand and enhance their confidence regarding their own ability to change
the reality on the other. In this way a process of self-reliant development is
initiated. The Ranna Vegetable Producers Co-operative Society is an example of
how independent small-scale producers could get themselves organized to find a
solution f o r themselves through a self-reliant development process. It has been
able to gain control over the surplus and control and manage the market in
addition to providing various other services either directly or indirectly to
the community.
38
--- page 47 ---
Discussion
The discussion session chaired by Dr. Chris Panabokke highlighted the
following points: a) Sarvodaya, the largest NGO, does not directly involve itself
in irrigation-systems management; b) it is difficult for the government agencies
to identify correctly the schemes to be rehabilitated and the NGOs could play
a crucial role in this connection; c) the NGO is important as a facilitator; and
d) donor contribution, mobilizing machinery, and other physical resources are
important factors to be reckoned with.
Dr. Panabokke noted that each NGO has a different approach and that there
is a need to clearly define the role of the N O . Mr. Joe Alwis claimed that an
NGO is essentially a helper rather than an organizer or a teacher. The biggest
advantage that the NGOs have over the government agencies is better comunication
with the farmers. He observed that most projects tend to collapse after
withdrawal of the "project" and the main aim of the NGOs should therefore be to
strengthen the farmers to stand on their own feet and build up self-confidence.
M r . Dayananda (UNDP/WFP)brought up the view that the general perception that
projects tend to fail after the withdrawal is an outsider's point of view.
However, it was observed that looking at it internally one may realize the impact
of the project.
Mr. Medagama argued that it is essential the NGOs and the government agencies
work together. Mr. Joe Alwis pointed out that it is difficult to generalize the
situation given the presence of a large number of variables. While noting that
the government agencies can learn a great deal from the NGOs the government
agencies can a l s o provide them with much needed support.
39
--- page 48 ---
Role of CARE in the Improvement
of Minor Irrigation Systems
M.C.C. Illangakmn
CARE (Co-operativeAmerican Relief Everywhere) is a recent entrant to the
Agrarian Sector having just formulated a four-year project on rehabilitation of
minor irrigation tanks. It has been presented to the donor agencies and it is
very likely that the project will be implemented soon.
pRoJM=T IDENTIFICATION
The fact that a large number of families are dependent on the minor
irrigation systems has provided justification for intervention by CARE.
Particular attention has been drawn to the relatively small extent of rice
cultivated during the yala season, and its direct relationship to the reduced
storage capacity of the village tanks which is due to inadequate maintenance
and continued silting over the years. This has resulted in the reduction of
crop area, yield, and even crop failures. A second crop in the yala season is
virtually impossible due to lack of irrigation water.
This has caused
malnutrition; this has also caused the farmers to resort to chena cultivation
practiced in the catchment area of the tank aggravating the problem through
accelerated soil erosion, loss of water storage in the soil, and environmental
deterioration.
Having identified and analyzed the problem besetting the agrarian communities
in the dry and intermediate zones, CARE has proposed that if the present waterstorage capacity of these tanks could be increased it will contribute to
increased cropping intensities and agricultural diversification and minimize the
incidence of chenaing, thus preventing further damage to the environment. The
process of intensification and diversification would lead to increased women’s
participation and nutritional standards of the families.
CARE’S perception of these problems and their interrelationship is admittedly
a result of its past activities with small farmers and their families on the one
hand and its appreciation of the relevant work done by institution like ART1 and
IIMI on the other. During the drought in 1987 CARF, was involved in a “food for
work” program which mainly concerned itself with restoration of small irrigation
tanks. Through need-assessment surveys and discussions that had been held with
farm families, tank committees, and other village-level officials the farmers
have aired their views of these problems and their suggestions on how to tackle
these problems. Relevant work of IIMI and ART1 has sensitized CARE on the
relative merits and demerits of various strategies as well as on the need to
train farmers in the economic use of irrigation water, the efficient management
40
--- page 49 ---
and maintenance of these small tanks, and the need to consult the farmers before
restoration work is undertaken.
The final goal of the project has been "To increase the income and improve
the quality of life of small farmers and their families who live on and cultivate
land irrigated by small village tanks." Under this final goal three major
objectives have been identified: a) to restore and rehabilitate 280 minor
irrigation tanks through de-silting, strengthening of bunds, and effecting minor
repairs; b) to increase the cropping intensity; and
c) to promote the
cultivation of vegetable and fruits in the home gardens, and consumption of the
same.
The strategy adopted by CARE involves the co-operation of the relevant
government agencies, mainly the Department of Agrarian Services and the
Agricultural Development Authority. A brief description of this strategy in
terms of each intermediate goal is given below:
Restoration and rehabilitation of minor irrigation tanks. The first
step is the organization of farmer groups and the election of the tank cmittee,
if none exists already, with a view to: a) explaining the nature of the work to
be undertaken; b) obtaining the views of the farmers; and
c) ensuring co-operation and participation of the farmers.
Farmers are expected to contribute 25 percent of the estimated cost
either by cash or labor and the Provincial Council and CARE would contribute 25
percent and 50 percent, respectively. The tank will be surveyed so that any
encroachment will be discovered. The encroachers are persuaded to quit and if
persuasion fails they are evicted by the Government Agent.
The Department of Agrarian Services would provide an earth-moving
machine and an operator. The tank committee would provide shelter for the
machine and its operator and security for the equipnent, fuel, and'oil at the
site. Desilting will not involve deepening the tank or raising the height of
the tank bund. Once the de-silted earth has been deposited as required the
earth will be consolidated and grass seeds planted.
Desilting operations are carried out in the dry season and the repair
work needed on the spill, sluice, pole points, and steps as well as on the
channels themselves would be undertaken once the desilting and the bund
strengthening work are completed.
Increase of cropping intensity. The activities identified in this
connection are the conservation and economic use of irrigation water, the correct
timing of cultural operations, the use of rain water for land preparation,
carefully controlled rotational water issues from the tank, and the adoption of
better cropping practices such as dry sowing and the use of new or improved crop
varieties which are less water-demmding but more profitable than rice for a
41
--- page 50 ---
second crop. It is expected that as a result of these activities, cropping
intensity will be increased from about 75 to 180. These innovations will involve
training classes for farmers and members of tank committees. The farmers will
require credit and marketing facilities and it is proposed to persuade
Multipurpose Cooperative Societies and Cooperative Rural Banks to provide these.
Cultivation of vegetable and fruits in home gardens. It is hoped that
by improving the diet which is deficient in minerals and vitamins the quality
of life of the farm family would be improved. It is therefore intended to
promote the cultivation of vegetables and fruits in the home gardens. This
enterprise will be undertaken by farm women and surplus family labor will be
utilized during slack periods in the cultivation of rice. With increased
production not only will consumption of these items be increased but a surplus
will also be available for sale thereby increasing income. This program will
also entail training classes for farm women on nutrition, techniques of vegetable
and fruit cultivation, and vegetable and fruit preservation.
Training. A large training component is involved in the realization of
each intermediate goal. The target groups will cover government officers, farmer
representatives and leaders, farmers,and farm women. The training program would
be timed for the period when the desilting operations and cultivation operations
for maha and yala are not being conducted.
M0NI”G
AND EVAIAJATION
The mechanism adopted involves field visits and observations at each
location, interviews with farmers and farm women, and scrutiny of any written
records maintained by farmers, farm women, and the government officials. Before
restoration work is commenced baseline data will be collected and at the end of
the second year formative evaluation is conducted which will recommend ways of
improving the implementation.
At the end of the fourth year there will be a final evaluation which will
measure the attainment of the final goal in terms of increases in the total
income, cropping intensity, and consumption crops produced in the home gardens.
42